This is not an official blog of the City. It is the work of Mark Kapel who is solely responsible for content.

Search This Blog

Thursday, June 14, 2012

The 353 Day and Still Ongoing Saga of American Tower and the City of Bloomfield Hills. Part 1

The surprise guest at Tuesday's City Planning Commission  meeting was a Public Hearing for the American Tower 140 foot Communications Tower planned for the DPW lot on Kensington Road,


If you don’t know much about this issue you are not alone.  Aside from the publication you are now reading  there has very little coverage. Even some of the Planning commissioners were confused and though perhaps the Tower has something to do with improved cell phone reception for residents which it does not. Perhaps it would be a good idea to begin at the beginning




 In 2011 and 2012 American Tower has appeared three  times before City Commission.


The first correspondence was sent to City Manager Jay Cravens on June 25th 2011. A copy of that correspondence can be found on the bottom left side of this  page  under the archived Post 2011/July/Communications tower , Stealth or otherwise.


A month later on July 26 2011 they appeared before City Commission at a 5 pm Monday Commission Work Session but made no formal presentation because they were told by Mr. Cravens that the agenda of that that day wouldn't allow for it.  The minutes of that meeting are below.


 77  days later on October 11th  American Tower was back with sketches that were shown only to the commissioners. The October 11th  Meeting minute notations are below.


Of note because they will be factor in future meetings  are the remarks of  then Commissioner (now Mayor) Sarah McClure and then Mayor (now Commissioner) Zambricki. 
Of particular note is the City Manager's statement that the City Commission should give authorization  before the planning commission hears the petition.


 133 days later at a February 21st 2012.  Mr Cravens told City Commissioners that American Tower was planning another visit. It seems they wanted to know if  the City would lease them the land a fact he mentioned at their last visit. The implication was why should they bother if the City would in the end decided not to lease them the land.


21 days later On March 13th  American Tower again appeared before City Commission. Mayor Zambricki was absent so the meeting was chaired by Mayor Pro tem  Sarah McClure.   City Manager Cravens sent the following correspondence t0 City Commissions which included detailed illustrations.







60 Days  Later on June 12th Planning Commission meeting agenda has the following agenda items...


The Planning Commission will consider the the request for a site plan to construct a wireless communications tower at 1805 Kensington Road , City of Bloomfield Hills Public Works Property.


It was presumed that American Tower would present the necessary information and documentation for the Planning Commission to approve the proposal and send it back to the City Commission for final approval.


 In anticipation of that American Tower was also an Agenda item on the City Commission meeting for that evening where it was expected final approval or further modifications to effect a conclusion  might be forthcoming.


Neither of the above occurred .



Why ? Maybe it's like homework which despite the passage of years and decades never goes away. There will always be forms to fill out and protocols to be followed. You can say that half of life is showing up that but does at the very least obligate you to show up.


On June 12th American Tower did indeed show up for the rpm Planning Commission meeting and did for all intents and  purposes do their homework. There was a proposal and and exhibits A, B, C, and D meant to make their points. Copies  of said may not have been distributed at the door but it had been submitted to the City and and put in the agenda packet for the meeting and on the City's web site.


It had also been graded by the city's consulting firms for zoning and engineering  and found to be deficient in points. Those deficiencies would preclude an immediate green light back to City Commission but was a start.


Let's look at what American Tower had after a year preamble to say in writing.












































No comments: